Excluding the Sufferer and Karkat, could any candy-red-blooded trolls have existed prior to SGRUB? or perhaps could they exist in a world like Hiveswap's? Also, if you have any knowledge on the matter, when does Hiveswap occur in canon? or is it its own separate canon?

sharklilly

Hiveswap occurs in the 90′s of B1 (john’s) Earth, I was to say 1994 more specifically but I’m not sure.  And the Alternian portion happens a significantly long time before Hivebent.   As for the candy bloods, it’s not entirely impossible that there were more.

I've been out of Homestuck for a few years because all of the pauses and whatnot. I've forgotten a great deal but want to finish it so is it worth rereading and finishing?

hd-scissors

Yeah man, reread that shit at your leisure, it’s better the second time

if the God tier kids got sick and died, wouldn't their acts through their lifetimes make them by default heroic and off them permanently?

foxwitchofvoid

Nope. The way they die has to be heroic. Previous actions don’t factor in at all.

Is karkat immortal like the others?

holycaribou

no

About Jane making Kanaya immortal, even if she could make someone immortal, it wouldn't work with Kanaya. When Jane was Crockertier, she said that using life powers on the undead kills them again.

shylittlestump-deactivated20190

Which was a bluff because we see Jane revive Kanaya in Collide

for the thing with vriska having blue shoes. its possible you guys are remembering another light player who had blue shoes...

Anonymous

Yeah, like I said, both of the other light players have blue shoes

If the kids still have their powers, would they still be immortal?

Anonymous

Yes

IF TEREZI FINDS VRISKA AND THEN JUST ATTACHES KANAYA TO HER BACK

Anonymous

You really Vriska would go for that though?

What's an egbert

williamhenrythefourth

image
Wait couldn't Vriska steal all the luck again and then just follow Kanaya around and jump in the way of everything so that it miraculously misses her and doesn't hit Kanaya?

Anonymous

Vriska’s not around though