People sometimes ask you about personal opinion, what do you think about Aranea? You think it is possible to redeem her?

mit-boy

Aranea definitely was a  Serket with all the standard Serket flaws and ideals. But I don’t think she’ll be redeemed. Heck, I’d be surprised if we even see her again.

Why does the GHB have more letters in his name then the other trolls? Ex. Mindfang-8 Redglare-8 Psiionic-8 Signless-8

Anonymous

It’s unknown why he has more

do you think it'd really be essential for the trolls to become godtier? personally, maybe it shouldnt be done for Karkat, in order to make him a more identifiable leader, but it would be cool if Terezi and Kanaya ascended.

raccoffee

Cool, yeah. Essential, no.

Have we ever seen Gamzee without his make up on?

Anonymous

no

How many trolls can become god their other than Aradia and vriska. (Unless jack killed the rest)

Anonymous

None of the currently alive trolls that haven’t ascended can ascend through any means that have been stated in canon.

I don't see how it would be lazy writing if it becomes necessary and someone is capable of doing so. In that case you could argue that Roxy appearifying a new Matriorb is lazy writing too. Or Jade saving the planets from the Beta session. Or John retconning the timeline.

Anonymous

I’m no English major so this isn’t a perfect analysis but,

It would be lazy because there’s been no build up to it. Creating a new Matriorb has been a thing for years and Roxy was forced into the role of attempting to create it by the Condesce, and then chose to continue to try to make it of her own free will.  Jade saving the planets was also an established plot point before hand as Echidna’s request was for Jade to do so. John’s retcon was kind of lazy writing but due to Homestuck being a webcomic Hussie was able to pull that off in part to the nature of the story.  This of course is only my opinion and you are free to yours but I just don’t think it would be strong for the story if Roxy just up and made the trolls’ slabs.

How exactly did the Psiioniic die again? And where is it mentioned?

Anonymous

He was killed by the Vast Glub

Were Jane and Jade sleeping during the entire three years in the meteor?

Anonymous

No.

When did kanaya become God teir (or is that only a fandom thing?)

Anonymous

She has not ascended

I'm a little confused about the stop motion animations featuring the alpha kids and caliborn. Was that foreshadowing the future or part of a different timeline or???????? And also- has Cal had caliborn's soul in him since the beginning?

theamazincactus

The claymation was of future events and Cal has always had the souls, this is explain in [S] MSPA Reader: Mental Breakdown